I miss features for commenting and downvoting. There are a lot of ideas on there currently which already exist.
Like Companies data API, Daisy Disk for personal finance and Email parser with categorization and actions
Like Companies data API, Daisy Disk for personal finance and Email parser with categorization and actions
I'm thinking of a button that says something like, "Not a good idea? Tell the owner why". And when you click, you'll be asked to tell the owner why. That feedback won't be visible publicly. But it'll be shared with the owner of the idea. And also, if you used that button on an idea, it'll by default be hidden from your view in the future.
If you have other suggestion on how to implement this, let me know!
With regards to engaging with users:
In the current design, the first two levels of interest that a user may show on your idea do not include sharing any contact information. Namely upvoting an idea, and signing up for updates. A user has to support your idea on level 3 ("share contact info with the project owner") or level 4 ("share your use case") in order for you to actually get their contact info.
For now, if you go to your "ideas" section, you'll already see the count of each level of support your idea got (upvoted, subscribed to updates, shared contact info, filled out questionaire).
The ability to actually send out an update to the users that requested it is actually still missing. Same goes for accessing the contact info of the users who shared it with you, and for accessing the info they shared with you when they filled out the questionaire. I didn't know if this Show HN was going to go anywhere. But I'm going to add these features. These contacts are yours. And they have entrusted me with forwarding their request to you.
Getting access to people's contact information would be useful at a later point in the process, but early on I think immediate feedback would be the most beneficial. Even something along the lines of a HN thread like this one would be enough engagement at first. In fact, perhaps that is even sufficient :)
I wouldn't want a public dialogue. Because that would signal public interest in the idea to outsiders. This is something that I imagine people posting an idea want to avoid, because they don't want to attract competition if the idea turns out to be a good one.
But it would be easy to have a two-way-conversation with the creator. So user john can post a message to idea owner thomas. Thomas can even reply, and they can write back and forth. But john will ever only see his own conversation with thomas, and never those that thomas might have with others, such as ben or lucy.
This is actually one of the major reasons I made the site, even though there's Hacker News. If my idea got traction on HN, it would attract more and more attention, and I'd have no way of pulling it from the site. Public interest in the idea would be documented for everyone to see, forever.