Hacker News Reader

I think one thing that this could help with is that, even if you are proficient in Lean, finding the way you are supposed to translate an informal statement into Lean/mathlib can be time-consuming if not a challenge -- it is a very large library, and it is mathematically heavy (being a library for theoretical mathematics). At the least, this gives you hints about which parts of mathlib you should be looking at.

View on HN

Maybe! You're certainly correct that there's a difference between knowing Lean (or a given proof assistant) vs. knowing mathlib (or some specific library). It doesn't seem to me that Codex has much of an idea about the mathlib codebase, since it e.g. invented and used "tangent_space_at_identity" out of the blue. Library-specific training would improve on this, of course.

I would reach for the usual code search tools for getting familiar with a library. For example, in Coq you have the "Search" and "Print Hint" commands which let you search for terms and instances, respectively. I imagine Lean has something similar.

> It doesn't seem to me that Codex has much of an idea about the mathlib codebase, since it e.g. invented and used "tangent_space_at_identity" out of the blue

But then perhaps it's a hint to the user that this API may be an useful abstraction, and perhaps one can use the same tool to define this function

Reply on news.ycombinator.com