Hacker News Reader

Comment by HWR_14 | Hacker News Reader

I have no idea what they think they are preparing for, but it sounds like the kind of people who want a new civil war. And those people tend to be bad.

View on HN

And apparently you don't know anything about history either.

or perhaps they are just fed up with bowing to a government that doesn't work for them? The USA was founded by terrorists too, from the POV of Britain...

"No, they are terrorists who want a civil war" is not the comeback you think it is. The people who think like that should be on watchlists and the registries that prevent them from buying guns.

The last civil war in the united states happened something like two life-times ago. Being prepared for the possibility of an unwanted civil war is not the same thing as wanting to start one. Given that war within the border of the US in a lifetime is historically well within "one unlucky 6-sided dice roll" it doesn't seem that weird of a thing for people to worry about, or possibly even somehow "prepare" for.

Which has nothing to do with the person I was responding to who talked about "bowing to the government" and how revolutionaries are always perceived as terrorists.

You're right. My reply would have been more appropriately placed at your parent post.

In that case, I would point out that trying to extrapolate a rate of civil wars from black swan events seems almost impossible. It's happened one time in US history (two if you want to count the American Revolution).

And how do these people's preparations help in the event of a civil war?

>> target practice and prepping for if shit hits the fan here in the US.

>And how do these people's preparations help in the event of a civil war?

(scratching my head how they would not)

Pure speculation.

Based off inconclusive evidence, I speculate that your name is Walter. Speculation is a valid form of discourse and has a non-negligible chance of being accurate. What is the value in your attempted invalidation of such discourse?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com