Hacker News Reader

Python would like a word...

While we're on Python and private methods - what's with everyone just _underscoring every method and variable by default? Does anyone teach people to do this or have I just ran into a few people with this habit by chance?

I know what _underscoring does in Python and what PEP8 recommends but doing it all the time for everything is so ugly and unnecessary.

I think it's because of what underscoring does. It's the "fake" privacy in Python. Also autocompleters tend to ignore those functions

Perhaps you worked with Java/C++ programmers using Python.

Probably for the same reason that zero-based versioning (https://0ver.org/) is so popular. People want to avoid commitment.

The language is not relevant to the question.

Making variables and methods private means making them inaccessible outside the class and I gave the typical reasons/best practices for that.

> Making variables and methods private means making them inaccessible outside the class and I gave the typical reasons/best practices for that.

The point they are making is in python there's no private method, everything is public. There's only a convention of "avoid using anything starting with "_"

Yes but that point is irrelevant to the question...

Reply on news.ycombinator.com