Hacker News Reader

Comment by iskander | Hacker News Reader

Is there a list of all 25 somewhere? This could provide some illumination on what SEC does and does not consider a security.

View on HN

Or maybe the SEC considers all of them securities but thought that they had the strongest case for these seven and didn't want the distraction of arguing about the other 18. But yeah, would be interesting to see the list.

If SEC considers any of them securities, it's very strange for them to go after a single guy at Coinbase and not the entire company, since they've just declared them an illegal securities exchange.

(As opposed to an illegal commodities exchange for bitcoin.)

I think maybe it's only strange if you assume the SEC has unlimited money and time. Grandparent comment says it better, but they're likely focusing on cases they think are pretty clear-cut.

I'm interested in cases like Rari where there was a decentralized governance mechanism but it was dominated by a "core team", that feels like it encompasses a larger slice of the space than I would have expected. Many of the others are deeply unsurprising though, they are US corporations, took VC investments, have active managerial teams which are all employees of that corp, and advertise themselves as working to increase token value.

Yeah and Coinbase just fired back: https://blog.coinbase.com/coinbase-does-not-list-securities-...

This will be the central issue of the case. It'll be interesting! Will Coinbase step in to defend this guy who they were going to fire, just to prove that they don't list securities?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com