Hacker News Reader

Comment by spicyj | Hacker News Reader

Note that the 3G is almost 3.5 years old now and few people still use it.

Here in Canada where the oligopoly of telcos locks you into 3 year contracts many people in my family still use their 3GS. In fact everyone in my immediate family with an iPhone has the 3GS (as did I until May when mine broke). Also worth noting that the 3GS has been sold up until this very day.

Some Canadians have been upgrading from the iPhone 3G this fall as well, which was sold up until summer 2010. My coworker just got a 4S and gave his 3G to his mom who now loves it.

I have no idea what it's like in SF and other similar places but there's a big world outside of California.

> Here in Canada where the oligopoly of telcos locks you into 3 year contracts many people in my family still use their 3GS.

Yep, can't stress this point enough and I don't know if its specific to Canada or not.

I just got off my contract with a 3G iPhone in September of this year. That phone was really starting to show it's age.

But this is exactly his point. Only in mobile devices is 3 years considered old to the point of irrelevance, and Android is far worse, closer to 3 months.

It can be justified on technological or economic grounds, but either way, environmental sustainability considerations clearly don't enter into the equation.

3 months for an Android phone be irrelevant is absolutely not true. My girlfriend has a Galaxy S (released June 2010) that runs every single game in the Android Market perfectly and was updated to Gingerbread (and maybe will be updated to ICS). It is not the best device out there but is still very relevant and she doesn't see a single reason to buy a new device.

My 4 was stolen and I got a used 3G off eBay for $100. Reasonable price, but it is frustratingly slow with iOS 4.2.1. The Facebook app is unusable.

The 3G is definitely obsolete by now.

Downgrade it to 3.1.3. My 3G feels as snappy as when I first got it. (Though, of course, you can't run some apps that require iOS4, e.g. Twitter.)

Definitely do this, unless you have an extremely critical must-have application that requires iOS 4.

The perf "gains" from going back to 3.1.3 make the phone non-irritating again.

I don't believe you can downgrade to 3.1.3 any more. When you restore an OS image, iTunes checks whether it is a valid image with Apple's servers. After a major version has been out for a while, Apple stop approving installs of older versions.

I might go the jailbreak route if it enables me to do that.

Wow, thank you for the suggestion! I'll definitely be trying it. I can survive with webapp Twitter until my next upgrade (or even next year for the new iPhone if it's bearable enough).

My wife still uses the original iphone. Still works great, but can no longer be upgraded.

You're looking at only the launch date, whereas there are still people who are locked into carrier contracts after having bought it. AT&T stopped selling it only in June 2010 which is not even a year and half back.

http://www.bgr.com/2010/06/04/att-officially-stops-selling-i...

Reply on news.ycombinator.com