And since there is no smashed window, insurance won't pay out either.If you have comprehensive insurance (which is what would cover a stolen car), they'll pay whether or not it was broken into, you left the keys in it, or even if you left the engine running while unattended.
https://www.progressive.com/answers/car-theft-with-keys-in-c...
As long as you have comprehensive coverage, you can file a claim if your car is stolen while left running. Comprehensive can still pay to replace your vehicle if it's stolen while your keys are inside it or if you left it running.
Car insurance won't pay for any personal effects stolen from the car, that would be covered by homeowners insurance, but as long as you have a police report, they'll cover it. I had a bicycle stolen from my (unlocked) car while parked in a garage -- homeowners insurance just asked for the police report, then sent me a check for the bike. They d