Hacker News Reader

Comment by hnarn | Hacker News Reader

You don’t really mention specifically what you find “frustrating” about VMWare Workstation so it’s hard to know on what criteria to give a response.

I don’t know how “built in” it can be considered but I’ve used LXD a bit and since it now supports VMs as well I’m guessing you could define VMs in yaml in advance and “easily” (depending on your definition) tear down and re-deploy VMs with preconfigured network settings etc. Vagrant should also work for this with a Virtualbox or VMware backend (paid feature).

What exactly do you mean when you say that the VM should be able to “interact with the host OS”, isn’t that exactly what you don’t want and why you’re running a VM in the first place?

View on HN

I'd like the ability to drop files to a VM from another VM, like shared folders in Workstation.

My frustrations with VMWare usually revolve around network connectivity issues. My internal or NAT networks often fail to give the guest VMs the expected connectivity.

You work in cybersecurity and want more exposure between the host and the guest? You have a very different risk tolerance than I would in your shoes

If I'm doing real malware execution and analysis, I would one- way transfer the relevant file(s) to my sandbox and disable any backward connectivity before execution, but I still need a reasonably simple way of getting files to (suspicious files, etc) and from (resulting logs, registry changes, pcap, etc) the malware sandbox. Ive kinda solved this already using a number of tools outside my work host, but just in the off situations where this is necessary I want to have a template VM prepped in advance.

https://wormhole.app/

I second this, it's called magic wormhole, if you want the source, croc is a more friendly solution built ontop of magic wormhole. In any event, quick and easy.

PSA: wormhole.app and magic wormhole are not the same

If you want to use the well known magic wormhole then visit the repo for instructions: https://github.com/magic-wormhole/magic-wormhole

The current supported version is a python cli app. A rust version is being developed, but last I checked was not considered ready.

> I'd like the ability to drop files to a VM from another VM, like shared folders in Workstation.

https://www.qubes-os.org/doc/how-to-copy-and-move-files/

Reply on news.ycombinator.com