Russia's ruble is the strongest currency in the world this year
cbsnews.com
cbsnews.com
The West does not depend on income from anything they export to Russia. Russian economy is small and poor, they don't buy much of anything and no one is going to go out of business, no country would suffer significant economic consequences even if all exports to Russia are banned outright, and this is more or less what happened.
Russian exports are another story, some nations by their stupidity (and well-targeted bribes), got too dependent on Russian energy. It takes more effort and time to ban them. And now we're in a place where imports into Russia are banned and exports, not so much, resulting in logical appreciation of Russian currency due to simple law of supply and demand.
It doesn't mean they are happy. Money is of little use if you can't buy much with them. USD in Russia is almost like a Soviet rouble now: feels nice in the pocket, but most things you'd want to buy with it, are no longer on stores' shelves.
Appreciation of currency serves an additional purpose of driving Russian non-raw-material exporters out of business making then uncompetitive because their rouble costs translate into too many dollars now.
Every country needs to not buy Russian goods or goods produced by another sanctioned country.
Every country needs not to sell goods to Russia or another sanctioned country.
All financial and commercial interactions between the Russia and its sanctioned supporters needs to cease.
For example, that means China and India should not be buying Russian oil and other goods. If they do, then they too will be sanctioned.
Likewise, countries that sell goods to Russia or other sanctioned countries, for example, aircraft parts, should themselves be sanctioned.
Aggressive sanctions can cause significant damage, disruption, even casualties.
Are there realistic models of the various economies that can be used to forecast the impacts of various sanction strategies? Where is there data on the economies of Russia, the Ukraine, and their global trading partners adequate to estimate impacts of different strategies.