All this ruling did was strike down the “may issue” requirements for concealed carry in NY.

Just like most of CA, a permit to carry came down to “do the police like your reason”. Which allowed a few well connected celebrities in NYC to carry and most everyone else was told to “no”. San Jose Sheriff (edit:nope, Santa Clara) was selling carry permits for fat donations to her re-election is another example of where arbitrary decisions were rampant.

The court says screening on objective criteria like risk to public, criminal and mental health background, etc are still allowed.