Hacker News Reader

Full thread

imron

> * Comments float above the code

> * Comment on any text selection in the file

> * Comments don't get lost when code changes

This addresses my main pet peeves with GitHub/Bitbucket reviews!

2 questions:

With regards to comments not getting lost, how well does this work across rebases and force pushes?

Are you considering supporting other products like Bitbucket and Gitlab?

View on HN

Comments should get transferred just fine across rebases and force pushes. If they don't, you can let me know using the feedback form at the top right.

Supporting other VCS providers, even non-Git ones, is on my list. The underlying data model is agnostic to GitHub so it's just a matter of having demand for it and doing the work!

Reply on news.ycombinator.com