Hacker News Reader

Comment by pclark | Hacker News Reader

Good grief — for one thing, teenagers vaping is a crisis.

That alone appears to render your entire comment moot, but I'll add that all of my comments today have been incredibly consistent: smoking cigarettes is really really really bad and vaping nicotine is really bad (because its addictive, there are longterm implications of inhaling nicotine, ...) - to put it another way, if you smoke combustible cigarettes then you should switch to vaping ASAP. But if you do not smoke combustible cigarettes do not start vaping because nicotine is highly addictive!

PS: equating nicotine to caffeine is incredibly stupid and offensive towards the millions of people that battle nicotine addiction every day.

View on HN

Respectfully, it feels as if you're not reading my or anyone else's posts in this thread. Yes, I do not advise someone start vaping nicotine if they're non-smokers. From everything I understand, there really isn't more harm in applying a nicotine patch a day compared to drinking a cup of coffee a day, assuming average/recommended doses.

Yes, nicotine can be addictive. Caffeine can also be addictive. Yes, nicotine can cause certain health problems - as can caffeine. I'm surprised you worked at a company that sold nicotine products and yet have such a moral panic mentality around a fairly mundane, mild cholinergic stimulant out there.

Smoking is terrible for one's health, but smoking cannabis is possibly not much healthier than smoking tobacco; people just smoke tobacco far more frequently per day than cannabis, typically. At least one study shows cannabis smoke is actually more likely to cause lung cancer than tobacco smoke when taking that into consideration. Odds are burning and inhaling the leaves of many other kinds of plants will have similar risks. This is not a defense of tobacco smoke on my part but rather an attack against any kind of combustion-based smoking period.

I mean caffeine and nicotine are roughly comparable, sure caffeine is less bad but it's still an addictive substance that's incredibly hard to quit, gives you crippling withdrawal, and has long term negative health effects, and is really easy to OD on if you ever stray from natural sources and commercial drinks with measured doses. People would be battling quitting caffeine everyday too if there was a huge push to do it.

You're allowed to acknowledge the odd double standard the world seems to have where because the most popular delivery methods for nicotine are extremely harmful that we treat nicotine itself as more harmful than it really is and say that we would still be better off simply banning nicotine. If it was an established cultural norm that gum just had nicotine in it and you had to buy "denic" gum like decaf there would never have been a massive push for people to quit.

Also, I think you're overestimating how many young people vape. I promise you it's not that cool.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com