Hacker News Reader

Pretty depressing that all review sites are potential scams. Do you feel there's any way that regulation or oversight could improve this?

View on HN

In Germany, we have the government-founded Foundation Warentest which has been known to provide high-quality and independent reviews for decades [1]; additionally our media such as the Heise publishing house (who have co-authored the industry agreement on how to run product reviews [2]) runs their own test series on products.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stiftung_Warentest

[2] https://www.heise.de/newsticker/meldung/Verbraucherschutzmin...

This is pretty much it. If the consumer is not paying for it in some ways (for example in the UK, consumers can pay Which?[1] to access their reviews) - the companies are.

If the companies are the ones footing the bill, I see no way to have a fair system where a few richer players couldn't exploit the system or the review company itself charge companies as much as they can just for leaving them alone and not rigging the reviews against them.

[1] https://join.which.co.uk/join/offers

Reply on news.ycombinator.com