I never used AOL, but as a kid, receiving the 3.5" floppy in the mail was really nice. Saved me having to buy one!
For youngins, 3.5" floppies had a "write protect" switch. If it was a solid plastic bit, you could write, but if the switch showed a hole, it would be treated as read only. Here's the first Google result I found: https://electronicstechnician.tpub.com/14091/css/Write-Prote...
Reusing the CDs was a little harder. ;)
You also drilled a hole on the other side to make the disk double density.
Those were sooo ubiquitous. But I never saved any, and now I wish I had some.
Luckily, the Smithsonian is on the job: https://www.si.edu/object/nmah_1395721