Back in the 1930s, the car companies established this system so that they could worry about making cars, and the franchises could worry about selling and repairing them.
Early on, though, the franchisees lobbied their state governments for protection. They feared, among other things, that the giant car companies could open up their own stores across the street, cut prices, and crush the franchise like a bug.
To prevent that kind of abuse, all 50 states passed “dealer franchise laws.” They protected the dealerships in various ways—including barring any car maker from selling directly to consumers.
Those laws didn’t foresee the modern era. What they meant, of course, is that “no car company that has franchises can sell directly to consumers.”
They weren’t even thinking about companies that don’t have franchises, because there weren’t any at the time.
Over the years, Tesla’s legal team has gone from one state legislature to another, pointing out how that rule has become outdated, and suggesting that it get changed. In some cases, they succeeded.
In others, though, Tesla is running into a tougher obstacle.