Another PayPal horror story: Gameolith, the linux game shop.
reddit.com
reddit.com
Even though this behavior sucks for small merchants, it's not uncommon.
I didn't issue a charge-back and got no option or say on the matter - it was reversed and i got an email from paypal after the fact without any question asked if I'd like to reverse it or not.
It was simply "your transaction has been reversed."