Hacker News Reader

Comment by mostertoaster | Hacker News Reader

I would definitely buy a manual if I could. Just more fun to drive. I think Honda civic’s lowest model might still have one. Not sure of anything else.

View on HN

If “fun” is the primary advantage (I know there are others) then it’s no wonder there’s fewer manuals in the US, at least. I think for many people, myself included, a car is a tool. I don’t need it to be fun. I need it to be reliable, easy to use, and as efficient as possible.

For some cars are a hobby, but for many people they’re most another tool in our lives.

Manuals have an advantage in some situations (off roading, transmission doesn’t overheat, better performance with skill, repairability) and autos have theirs (easy, better fuel economy)

If I commuted to an office every day I’d get an auto (actually these days an EV), but working in the bush/backroads? Manual

All those points, except for repairability, are arguable for modern gearboxes such as DSG.

Modern autos still have the overheating issue? Not an issue on road, becomes an issue offroad when your really pushing the vehicle

Yeah if I still lived in Seattle area and drove to work I’d want an automatic.

As it is I don’t deal with traffic so a manual is a more fun “tool” to drive.

Well, and fun on a windy country road is a heck of a lot less fun commuting in stop and go traffic.

Even in a stop-and-go traffic jam, a manual transmission will be the least of your worries.

Looking at what cars people buy, fun and prestige seem huge contributers to purchasing decision. Otherwise there is really no way to explain how SUVs are the best selling cars and how a significant portion of buyers opts for way overpowered cars.

As someone who just owned a manual Mini Cooper for about 18 years, I recommend that. The manual combined with the way the Mini is designed, with the wheels pushed way out to the corners, firm suspension and incredibly responsive steering, is a real joy. It's a feeling of complete control of the car and constant awareness of exactly where all four corners of the car are. So easy to parallel park these older Minis, too, before they kept making them larger and larger.

Hard to find this in any current cars, especially affordable ones.

Corolla comes in a hatchback with a manual.

I did my part and bought a manual VW. The problem was reselling it. Nobody wanted it.

Pretty much every compact/subcompact still has a manual option.

If you want a crossover I think the only new one that still has a manual is the Crosstrek.

Golf R

Reply on news.ycombinator.com