Abandoning Activism

justinmoses.net

2 points·justinj··3 comments

"Clearly they lack consolidation and any real agenda for change. But hell, you have to admire their stoicism. They’re dancing and singing as the weather slowly deteriorates into a cold soggy mess. And you know what? They’re smiling."

What bothers me about seemingless aimless activism though is that it can be easily manipulated. And even if it isn't manipulated, groupthink can be just as bad and chaotic (as is the case with riots). These people would be better off consolidating and meeting with people of like minds in a more organized fashion on a continual basis rather than getting together with people that have intent far from their own.

agreed - there is a wasted opportunity and the potential for misuse (though in my experience there is only so much tolerance for manipulation).

what i find quite interesting about the entire debate is how it has engaged the workforce. while many don't agree with the protesters outright, they're at least talking about some of the issues and challenging some of the status quo, and i see value in us having those discussions.

The problem is that it challenges the "status quo" in way that many find ignorant, misguided, flailing. Those that have fond teenage or college memories of the 60s (which I don't) would appreciate the protests, megaphone speeches, and drum circles. But to me, I'd find these people much more intelligent if they were meeting on their own regularly and quietly and sending letters to their senators, becoming engaged in politics and running for office.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com