Hacker News Reader

If you get a bill in the mail, how does "monopoly on violence" come into play?

It’s just a buzzword phrase free marketers use for every situation where the government does something.

I do wonder what the alternative they would prefer be though. Would they rather an individual be able to hire a private gang to collect the noise violation payment at gunpoint?

Can you choose to ignore the bill without any threat of state sponsored violence? If no, thats your monopoly on violence right there.

Never heard of violence upon someone for not paying a ticket. They might have their credit affected, their wages garnished, their vehicle registration suspended, and so on, if they continue to ignore bills. That isn't violence, but it is consequences.

But I'm curious how you'd prefer it be handled.

What if I don't pay rent? Should I be allowed to live there forever, simply because no one, not even the police, is allowed to physically remove me from the property if I refuse to pay and refuse to leave? I wonder how this ideal world you imagine actually works.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com