Hacker News Reader

What the Inclusionists seem to miss is the fact that an encyclopedia isn't The Hitchhiker's Guide or Angelfire,

No, we're all quite aware of that.

I claim that you are not, because your points don't cohere with the concept of an encyclopedia.

A compendium of knowledge can't be a compendium of knowledge if it has too much knowledge in it?

Again, you can't win an argument by pulling out a dictionary. Wikipedia is clear about what its goals are.