Comment by wolverine876 | Hacker News Reader

Comment by wolverine876 | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

In fields where I have expertise, the Reddit discussions I've seen are worse than nothing - the wrong answers to the wrong questions. I find them a waste of time, with very rare exceptions.

Perhaps I'm painting with too broad a brush, and some subreddits are valuable?

> curated content from true experts _tends_ to be a lot better (finding those experts is obviously hard)

Yes! I would love a search engine that is limited to high-quality sources. Technically it seems simple: Just limit indexing to expert/professional/high-quality domains. If I look up something in the field of science, show me results from Nature, the NY Times science section, AAAS, conferences, Scientific American, etc.

Some valuable content would inevitably be omitted, but we live in an age of information overload - I would much rather omit a few things than deal with the 99% low quality info.

You can already accomplish this by defining relevant sites in your query.

Maintain a few lists of sources you deem authorities in various disciplines, and voila…

While I agree the current state of search is pretty brutal, it’s still a slight improvement over the limitations of a physical library or encyclopedia.

That said, IMHO it’s unreasonable to expect any ‘search engine’ to be able to capture the intent of your brief query string, survey the current authorities (simply determining said authorities is contentious enough), and return the type of results you’re describing - in countless languages and across infinite disciplines, no less

Don't you know where are the experts... if you know where they are you only need to customize your search in Google to get the best results. Don't be so lazy, human intelligence is far more discerning that any available AI at the moment, most everything that champs AI or Machine Learning is neither anyways.

>Yes! I would love a search engine that is limited to high-quality sources.

I'm pretty certain Google ranks pages higher if they are viewed as authorities.

Also, I think quroa does this

Yes

E-A-T: Expertise, Authoritativeness, Trustworthiness

They don't weigh it nearly heavily enough IME. Most of the search results are useless.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com