So you wouldn't be in favor of a carbon tax? What about a tax on tobacco sales in a universal healthcare system? (to offset tobacco users' additional healthcare costs)
Maybe there should be a tax rebate for smokers, so they can buy more cigarettes?
And “sin taxes”, i.e. tobbaco taxes and carbon taxes are a logical fallacy.
Tobacco tax won’t offset the additional healthcare costs for smokers on average, so it ends up just being a penalty for having a bad habit, and carbon tax will simply put a price tag on high carbon emissions.