Doesn't that assume the distribution at time 1 is also the distribution at time 2, which isn't entirely true since the source is already sightly less radioactive then?
If the activity is decreasing at a linear rate, then A+D and B+C should have exactly the same distribution. In reality, they will be ever so slightly different because the decay is exponential rather than linear, but over short periods of time (compared to the half-life) the linear approximation is extremely good.