These scenarios always result from watering down actual security.
One time the manager pointed at me and said with a smile, "You're trouble."
There was a (presumed dead) Canadian terrorist with my name.
This is exceedingly dumb if true. Numerical adjacency of SSNs is completely meaningless.
(The above is a joke, I'm guessing US government systems can't handle non-ASCII characters, and a German named Müller would have to be Mueller or Muller)
I don't have a particularly common name but when I google it I share it with an English football player and someone from South Africa who has been convicted of real estate fraud.
I've never been to South Africa but I have worked for a real estate portal, and it's on my LinkedIn (which I barely use, but still). I can see how someone outside would not be able to separate the two.