Hacker News Reader

That assumes the immigrants don't become part of the tax-paying economy, which they have a great record of doing.

Will they become high earners? The vast majority of taxes are paid by high earners and the wealthy, with those making under ~$43,600 a year—50% of Americans—paying just 3% of income taxes. (Source: https://www.heritage.org/taxes/commentary/1-chart-how-much-t...)

Maybe? Certainly it must be easier to attain higher income if you're legally allowed to be and work in the country.

Existing Medicare funding comes (mostly) from payroll taxes, not income tax, and the two work very differently.

It'd be more informative to look at who's funding healthcare now, including the private portions. I doubt very much that the bottom 50% are only covering 3% of that.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com