Hacker News Reader

Comment by ig1 | Hacker News Reader

Not really. Do you think Ford aren't a company, how about Vodafone, BP and UBS ? - these are all companies which have filed annual losses.

Yes the purpose of a company is to make money, but not making money in the short term doesn't mean it's not a company.

Not all business are inherently self-sustaining in a short time period, many small business (including shop, restaurants, etc) will operate at a loss in their first year.

There's plenty of business that take a while to return a profit, that doesn't make them any less businesses just because they're not the type of business that you'd like to run.

View on HN

My larger point is these "companies" appear to have no interest in making money. I'm not suggesting you need to be making money every single minute of your company's existence.

Instead, I'm suggesting that you should be interested in (and actively working toward) making money.

The fact they're raising investment is a pretty clear statement that they want to make money. Just because they're not choosing to focus on revenue at this stage of product development doesn't really mean they have no interest in making money.

Any company needs to decide where their focus should be, Tumblr may well have done the analysis and decided that rather than take their focus away from their core product and focus on monetization (which may only generate a few hundred million in revenue at this stage) it's better for them to focus on their core product now in order to have a chance of monetizing at the billion dollar range in the future.

It's a perfectly rational economic decision.

Tumblr was founded in 2007. That makes it nearly 4 years old. Twitter was founded in 2006. That makes it nearly 5 years old.

At what point in their "Humble Beginnings" do you suggest they start thinking about making some money and becoming self-sustaining?

Somewhere along the way they need to focus on being able to provide for themselves. Otherwise it's a giant ponzi scheme where all you get are investors investing in a product that won't return their investment.

At the point where it makes more sense to focus on monetization rather than growing the user-base in order to maximize the lifetime revenue of the company (as opposed to current revenue). It's silly to put some arbitrary deadline on something which should clearly be based upon company metrics.

If Ford, Vodafone, BP and UBS continued to file losses, then, no, they wouldn't be companies either. In fact, UBS probably won't be at the current rate they are barreling towards ruin.

Number one rule of business: make a profit, any profit.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com