And on the other hand, there are people that, after having tried it out, like it so much, that they are strongly for this way of working.
I think teams will form around both ways of working, and this might become a deciding factor on joining a team.
My point was to give my perspective from someone who would not like it, and how much I wouldn't like it.
I would definitely look for another job if forced to do this type of coding, as it would be very uncomfortable.
If it's optional that's great, but since it involves a team as its premise someone may be forced if the majority or the more influential people want it.
In that case the minority can go find a place that respects their process, but the manager should know of that potential unintended side-effect.