Hacker News Reader

Comment by tyingq | Hacker News Reader

It looks like you've already put in a lot of work to parse out individual specs and data for the tires. I bet you could inject a paragraph or 2 of text using that, and place that on the pages somewhere. Just make a few different templates with some random phrasing to generate variations, like:

- This off-road tire features a track width of xxx mm, making it perfect for...

- Designed for off-road use, this tire is xxx mm wide, and features...

- Schwalbe, a German manufacturer, produces this xyz model of tube for...

...

View on HN

Am I the only one shocked that this is required ? This is essentially advocating for SERP spam, which is the bane of my existence.

Websites with generic sentences like this make everyone lose their time when they are looking for tangible information.

If Amazon asks for that kind of shitty content to justify the existence of a valuable site like yours, I’d skip them entirely and search elsewhere to monetize…

I think you can take this to a point where it's SERP spam, but what I was suggesting doesn't fall into that category, at least to me. A paragraph or two of descriptive text with actual info supplied by a specs table seems reasonable to me. Some people may even absorb info better when done that way.

My suggestion (as a reply) for spintax is a little closer to spam, especially if you get carried away. Done right, though, it's not very different from what a copy writer would do manually. Products have product descriptions, and they are somewhat formulaic even when a person writes them.

If you poke around the site, you can see that time was spent parsing out various specs that aren't understood by other similar sites as anything other than strings of text. The tweaking would mostly be to get Amazon to accept it.

From what they describe it’s not “required” by Amazon — sounds like they don’t want that sort of automated/database-oriented content at all.

What you are reacting to is a way to trick Amazons bots and the underpaid bored agents looking over affiliate sites.

Now, you know why recipes all have that bullshit "story" above the actual recipe.

Affiliate programs act like "human interest stories" are the only way to make people intrigued or some such horse shit some MBA probably came up with and we all now have to suffer.

As you say, the sites are the way they are because that is what search engines and affiliate programs reward.

Generate filler content with GPT-3.

Cool idea, thanks! I will give it a try.

There's also templates that can do "spintax", so you get more variations, like:

{The|This} tire {is $width mm wide|{features|has} a {track |}width of $width mm}}

Thank you, I have not heard of Spintax before. Nevertheless, I will try to provide added value for readers in the texts.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com