Turbulence Equations Discovered After Century-Long Quest
scientificamerican.com
scientificamerican.com
Spectral link of the generalized Townsend-Perry constants in turbulent boundary layers Björn Birnir, Luiza Angheluta, John Kaminsky, and Xi Chen Phys. Rev. Research 3, 043054 – Published 21 October 2021
https://journals.aps.org/prresearch/abstract/10.1103/PhysRev...
Since Reynolds (1842–1912) proposed Reynolds averaging, there have been numerical approximations for turbulent flow. This paper proposes one more, perhaps better, such approximation for turbulent flow near a wall.
SciAm is totally blowing this out of proportion with their title.
If someone proposed yet another heuristic solution algorithm to the Travelling Salesman Problem, you shouldn't write an article "NP-hard problems finally solved after 50 years".
A pretty specific kind of turbulence modeling has been improved, this is not some grand general analytic theory of turbulence.
This paper provides an interesting connection between the spectral properties of turbulence and the second-order moments of velocity in boundary layers (the "spectral link" as the title says). That is interesting to experts but it is a bit too abstract for the general public to understand easily, unfortunately.
If you want to see a fun example of fluid dynamics approximations, look at the Wikipedia pages for the Darcy friction factor and Colebrook white equation.
I’m pretty stoked by these results.
(Sorry about the pun)
It is an incremental, but perhaps significant improvement for describing flow in a certain situation. It is nothing like a general purpose “solution” to turbulence.
Scientific American kind of sucks.
Yeah Scientific American sucks ass but this is an important area of research and it's ripe for a (or many) breakthroughs.
Does it make sense to say “someone discovered an equation for X”? If not, what would be a better word?
If it's just a fluke then more often and not I'd expect to see that spelled out as either context, or with the words you used: "stumbled upon".
At any rate, I think the reason it's used in this context in particular is because it represents that the 'equation' is not just a mathematical construct someone came up with, but that it represents observable reality in a way that is novel and perhaps unexpected. It wasn't something someone made up, it's something that usefully describes phenomena that are outside human control. Thus, they did not invent, instead they discovered.