Ask HN: Would you like for HN to have a collapse thread feature? | Hacker News Reader

Ask HN: Would you like for HN to have a collapse thread feature?

10 pointsdaanlo11 comments

I love the side and meta discussions and comments that happen on HN, but sometimes I just want to read the next comment that responds to the actual content of the article. Would be lovely to be able to collapse a sub-thread (the way you can in many IDEs). Would other users find this helpful as well?

View on HN

That's been existing for quite a while now? The "[–]" link at the end of each comment summary line.

Thank you very much :) I obs feel a bit stupid now, but I would have never guessed that is what the dash does :)

No worries, I think more commonly the collapse link is on the left side. Glad it helped!

... but HN has a collapse thread feature?

Yes. Yes. Yes. To the point where I've almost tried to copy some HackerNews source code and complete a POC myself.

Others have commented that this feature already exists. And yes "technically" it may exist, but I'm guessing that you mean "by default". I absolutely agree that I should be able to set collapsible threads as the default.

It never fails on HN, that on some topic, the first/top comment and its replies span the _entire_ page! That's terrible UX! We want to see what other people have to say.

As a user/reader, let me dig into conversations/threads that I find interesting without having to scroll through pages and pages. Who's to say there aren't more interesting discussions buried underneath the top comment thread? Dang always has to post reminders saying to "not forget these pages of comments". If we had a collapsible thread, I believe he wouldn't have to do that as much.

This could be implemented with little-to-no fancy JS/whatever -- so that HackerNews remains as barebones as it is. Even better - if you let users choose whether or not they want the collapsible comments feature by using a setting on the user profile view. Everyone wins :)

... what exactly are you missing from the existing implementation? you click the [-] and the thread is collapsed, what else do you want?

Yeah, I'm also getting confused. Collapsible threads are enabled by defaults, unless I'm missing something. Maybe it's now about collapsed by default, i.e. you have to expand any comment thread you want to read?

> ... be able to set collapsible threads as the default

HN has collapsible threads...they are not collapsed by default...

ok, yeah, but they are collapsible by default, just not collapsed, that what confused me with that statement :D

There's a collapsed feature.

If you are in a child comment, you can click on next to go to the next comment/discussion

Check out Hacker Brain (link in bio) for pre-collapsed threads.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com