Hacker News Reader

Are you working on an FPGA re-implementation? Basically everything with a DX7 chip in it is insanely priced (especially the PLG cards for the Yamaha MU-series, those are >$400), so this would be awesome to have.

View on HN

I do wonder if it's feasible just to use some cheap off the shelf (COTS) general purpose ARM cpus like in Rasperry Pi computers and some code to perform the same calculations that Yamaha did in an ASIC in 1980's in real time. Even PIC microcontrollers today have a decent amount of computation for a couple cents.

Being latency sensitive here is definitely key.

Someone ported an emulator to the teensy: https://github.com/dcoredump/MicroDexed

It certainly is. The Korg Volca FM is implemented in this fashion, just to name one. From memory it uses an ARM Cortex-M chip for both the UI, and DSP. Many other modern synthesisers use COTS general purpose chips for DSP these days. At some point around the late 90s synths made the transition from being built around custom ASICs to using COTS DSP processor chips. It's hard to pin down exactly when this became standard. The Roland JP8000 (1996) used custom ASICs for signal processing, the Access Virus (1997) used a COTS DSP processor, from memory (Something from NXP?). The Korg MS2000 (2000) had a COTS DSP processor too. These days you can apparently achieve comparable performance with Cortex-M chips.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com