Hacker News Reader

Comment by sillysaurusx | Hacker News Reader

This is mistaken, sort of. The first day was prior to this by many months. The “past” link doesn’t let you get to it unless you manually edit the url. Think of it like a secret Easter egg.

I’m on mobile but maybe I’ll do it later. Or one of you could claim the honor of discovering and sharing it.

Initially I suspected that all the people on the actual-first-day weren’t actually people — that pg seeded HN during its early days, much like Reddit, with multiple personas that only seemed real at a glance.

But now I think pg emailed a link to all@ycombinator.com and those initial users were the people from the 2005 batch. Then they collectively lost interest (which accounts for the multi month gap) at which point pg made it public as Startup News.

I would give a hint on how to find the real first day, but I think I like leaving it as an open puzzle. As a hint, pay close attention to the URLs on the page that this submission points to.

View on HN

Looks like this is it:

https://news.ycombinator.com/front?day=2006-10-09

Anything earlier gives HN didn’t exist yet.

You win the prize!

The casual conversation between pg and sama on the top link is interesting. Also neat that Sam was like 17 at the time.

I didn’t know the “HN didn’t exist yet” error. That’s neat, because it implies that this page was intended to be a secret Easter egg, rather than it being a bug.

The last interesting tidbit is to go forward starting from that day, and pay close attention to how rapidly organic interest in the site went to zero. It’s astonishing that Startup News didn’t suffer the same fate; it’s the hardest part of launching something like HN.

I still 40% suspect that lots of the early activity was artificial, and that real users eventually supplanted the artificial activity.

pg once alluded to a “secret sauce”, and I think it was as simple as “keep the front page fresh and interesting each day,” which absolutely requires manual intervention. So the secret sauce seems likely to be something along the lines of “have a big backlog of interesting links, then automatically submit them and give them a few artificial upvotes each day.”

I’ll admit, I’m probably more obsessed with HN’s early days than I should be. But it’s such a pleasing example of Lisp proving its value that I can’t help it.

Whey does it have many posts on the first day unlike my services?

I see 18 posts and 6 unique posters, if I've counted correctly. It's probably easy enough to get 6 of your friends to post for a day. After that is when it gets hard. Skip ahead a month and see what the post volume is like.

I'm curious to know if HN did a "Show HN" else where, or if the traffic organically snowballed.

Look at the next days. It had a gradual start

It's easy if you have access to a big list of users from somewhere else.

I used to run a stack of private torrent trackers. The first one I made came from the fact that the admin of another site ran off with all the funds and abandoned the users. I moved them all to my site. Then every time I set up a new site I had thousands of users I could message to let them know. On the final one I had 100K+ active users - a message to them was like having your own private army to do your bidding for you.

That's what I want to experience in my life.

That makes a lot more sense, all the usernames are green, unlike the posted link ;)

Reply on news.ycombinator.com