I'm genuinely curious to hear which database is the winner from your perspective based on Jepsen's insight?
FWIW, I think you're raising really good questions in this thread. Qualitative safety is highly contextual, depending on fault model, significance of individual operations, concurrency, throughput, latency demands, operational characteristics, data volume, etc etc., and I try to touch on that in the "Toward a Culture of Safety" section in this report. Hopefully that resonated for you.