Your example of Ramen Rater is the #1 result for the query [instant noodle reviews]. The more broad [instant noodles] has Wikipedia as the #1 result, which covers the "about" intent case you mentioned.
Your example of Ramen Rater is the #1 result for the query [instant noodle reviews]. The more broad [instant noodles] has Wikipedia as the #1 result, which covers the "about" intent case you mentioned.
I didn't specifically want instant noodle reviews. I just wanted sites about instant noodles. If they happen to be reviews, cool. If they are photo galleries, that's cool too. Message boards, also cool. But I don't want articles or encyclopedia or dictionary entries about instant noodles. I want full sites, or at least large subsections of sites, where the primary topic is instant noodles. This is what directories list. Sites where you open the site and ask "what's this site about" and the answer is clearly "instant noodles". Not at the page level, but at the site level.