Hacker News Reader

Anachronistically.

There is no seed. The seed concept was only invented years after Satoshi left. Early wallets had no seed. They were collections of random keys. That’s why so much early coin is lost. No way to rederive random keys.

Sorry about your dreams of satoshis 12-24 words, but this is not how it was.

View on HN

It is theoretically possible that one of said early private keys is randomly derived from a memnoic phrase. The chances however are miniscule.

In fact, all possible keys are derivable from a single seed. The BIP32 algorithm run for all inputs will produce all possible 256-bit ints. Of course, finding the path derivation is equivalent to brute forcing the key space anyway.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com