Hacker News Reader

Comment by dugditches | Hacker News Reader

Haven't heard anyone or news mention the fact Young tried to start his own music service a while back. And that his catalogue was a selling point.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pono_(digital_music_service)

View on HN

Oh, golly, the Pono. That's $400 I won't get back, so don't get me started. Oh, wait.

http://tenfourfox.blogspot.com/2015/01/and-now-for-something...

Heh, I had one of those players as well. A coworker of mine purchased it, didn't use it often and when he decided to use it for biking, it stopped working. In the meantime the company went out of business and he couldn't even get it serviced. So he gave it to me. I did manage to fix it after waiting for spare parts for many weeks.

The reason why it looks like a Toblerone bar is because they decided to use through-hole electrolytic capacitors (because audiophile reasons) and the battery was round too (an 18650 IIRC): http://mikebeauchamp.com/wp-content/gallery/pono-teardown/ca...

The triangular shape and inability to carry it comfortably in jeans pants pockets doomed it from day one. I'm amazed something like this passed the design stage. And first encounter with user testing would have made it crystal clear that the shape was a no-go. Yet it not only got funded but was also mass-produced. It was a massive waste of money.

I mean, it plays, and the audio quality was good (doubtful it was due to the reasons they claim, but it was good). But I hated the screen and you're right, the form factor would have never passed a focus group that tried to actually use it.

Discontinued April 2017

Must not've been that great of a selling point

It was expensive compared to spotify and the file sizes where way larger, since the files where in loseless format, something that is very niche, since most people cant tell the diference beetween a good quality mp3 and other formats.

It went a little further than that. IIRC it was specifically higher quality than the human ear could possibly hear. Young's response to this rational, science-based criticism was just pathetic; actual fact-based reasoning had no chance against his ego.

Excuse me if this latest drama of his makes me roll my eyes.

Let's not forget the hiper expensive player that came together, the Pono. How the Hell was you suposed to put that thing in your pocket with that triangular shape?

Yeah, that's all I immediately think of when I think of Neil Young. Griping about mp3 quality and nonsense no average listener cared about. He's probably very pleased to be off some streaming mumbojumbo site he already hates, and got to put out some positive PR about his 'principles' at the same time. Whatever. Anyone who cares about his music either owns hard copies or finds it on other things like youtube heh

I wonder if the Pono was the inspiration for the pyramid from the Office: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yZBVnjXp7GQ.

The Pyramid predates the Pono by half a decade.

Funny to see the man who tried to sell a high-definition audio snakeoil music player deciding to suddenly listen to scientists.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com