Comment by whitej125 | Hacker News Reader

Comment by whitej125 | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

>> Because fear.

What's funny is... whenever you call an FA (financial advisor) in a moment of panic... they answer always is "don't act emotionally and stick to the plan". Maybe a real "robo-advisor" should just be a chatbot that responds to any message it gets with "HODL".

>> Because unfamiliarity.

This one is going to be interesting to watch evolve and I see it becoming less of an edge for financial advisors. More and more, we are seeing retail investors gain familiarity (not saying knowledge... but at least familiarity) with financial markets through blogs, social media, etc. I think we are moving to a world of more self-directed investors than advised investors.

Some interesting articles to that effect:

https://www.wsj.com/articles/rich-millennials-to-financial-a...

https://www.wsj.com/articles/fidelity-once-stodgy-and-adrift...

https://www.m1finance.com/blog/the-rise-of-financial-influen...

> What's funny is... whenever you call an FA (financial advisor) in a moment of panic... they answer always is "don't act emotionally and stick to the plan". Maybe a real "robo-advisor" should just be a chatbot that responds to any message it gets with "HODL".

My robo-advisor did, during the giant tumble the markets took during the beginning of this pandemic, put up a message on the site & send a pro-active communication saying, essentially, to HODL. (In more eloquent terms, of course.) I presume a human had a hand in it, ofc., as they likely understood the fear most people would feel looking at the graph.

(My mistake, really, was not buying more at the bottom.)

I do recall that one of the features that Wealthfront had was to design their UX in a way that discouraged behaviors like frequently checking the valuations, making it annoying to make emotional transactions, etc, etc. Rather than having a human tell you to be calm, they tried to mediate behavior through UX patterns.

That's interesting. I did notice that the Wealthfront UX was really well done.

For example, during the onboarding they direct you to set up recurring investments and they show you in real time what that small investment might become by retirement age. That simple mechanic, which nobody else seems to do in that way during onboarding, makes it really obvious that you need to set that recurring deposit to be as high as you can possibly afford.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com