Hacker News Reader

Comment by Shank | Hacker News Reader

You’ll have access to your app purchases, but you won’t be able to get email at that address. For example, that means you won’t be able to get email receipts about subscription renewals, about purchases being refunded, or any other pertinent information that google might choose to send over email.

It’s better than cutting everyone off entirely, but far from ideal. You’re basically left with a half cancelled account at that point.

Edit: See @jsnell’s followup. In this response, I totally forgot that you could just change the MX records and continue to use the Google Account. I don’t know why I thought this.

View on HN

Of course you'd be able to receive email at that address, but you cannot have that email address be hosted for free at Google. You'd need to self-host, or pay somebody else to host email for that domain.

So back to the days where you could make a Google account with any email address before gapps exited. It was such a mess once domains where moved to gapps to know if it was a legacy account or gapps account. In fact I will still get prompted for some addresses.

> So back to the days where you could make a Google account with any email address

You can still do that, and it's not some obscure feature but asked about on the first page of the account creation flow with the "use my current email address instead" button. It'll be a fully functional Google account, except for supporting mail, and can be changed to a gmail account later (that feature is obscure though).

My guess would be that these legacy accounts will end up as something different than a consumer Google account created with a non-gmail address, but guess we'll see once it launches.

Ah yes, I feel like I totally forgot this. Thank you for pointing it out — you could totally just change the MX records and still use Workspace. I stand corrected! Thank you, Jason!

You don't need to self-host or host somewhere else either. You can use regular free GMail with a custom domain of your choice. I do this with mine.

Info? Because Google Apps for your domain also known as G Suite (legacy) is the method we've used for this and is going away as a free option. The other approach is to integrate a free gmail account with a mail hosting provider. You can use mailgun or similar to do it cheap but it still means you host your domain email server somewhere.

Google domains lets me do it for free.

True, my domain is also from Google domains (it's a .dev). I didn't think this feature was exclusive to that, but maybe it is.

Sounds like you might be using the free Google email forwarding feature outlined at https://domains.google/get-started/email/ To directly receive and send email from your custom domain Google upsells you to Google Workspaces https://domains.google/learn/how-to-use-email-forwarding/

Some other domain providers do offer email forwarding so its not exactly a Google exclusive.

I'm experimenting with CloudFlare's email forwarding (currently in beta) and it works very nice. Also, it's free and doesn't require changing registrars.

It is possible to have a google account without gmail

Yes, if you sign up for Google Cloud Identity you can create Google accounts without Mail, Calendar or Chat.

I wonder how hard it is to migrate to Google Cloud Identity from Gsuite after moving the MX & such away.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com