Hacker News Reader

The author states that pihole sending requests to 8.8.8.8 (Google) is worse than sending requests to your ISP. I disagree. I have always had terrible experiences with Comcost's DNS. I trust them less.

View on HN

It's not sending requests to your ISP, just via your ISP (and readable by your ISP)

Maybe I misunderstood what this does. Is unbound not sending requests to the ISP in this case?

I'm pretty sure it is using pure DNS recursion, so if you ask for abc.google.com, the pi itself will ask the com TLD DNS server for google.com's DNS server, then go and ask google what abc.google.com's IP address is

So you're not asking the ISP for abc.google.com, but because they provide the internet, the ISP will see all your requests, including the UDP request to the .com TLD, google.com's DNS, etc

Reply on news.ycombinator.com