Ask HN: New YouTube hover feature? Does anyone else find this annoying? | Hacker News Reader

Ask HN: New YouTube hover feature? Does anyone else find this annoying?

143 points37104 comments

I noticed on the youtube homepage that I cannot hover over a video thumbnail without it getting big and auto playing a portion. Does anyone else find this annoying as hell?

I understand the argument about how people don't like change (which will probably be the first counter to my complaining) but this is somewhat overstepping a line for me.

What say you, HN?

View on HN

I've blocked these popups and the suggestions overlay at the end of videos by using these rules:

  www.youtube.com##.ytd-thumbnail-overlay-loading-preview-renderer
  www.youtube.com##.ytd-video-preview
  www.youtube.com##.ytp-ce-covering-overlay
  www.youtube.com##.ytp-ce-element
  www.youtube.com##.ytp-cards
  www.youtube.com##.ytp-cards-teaser
  www.youtube.com##.ytp-cards-button-icon

Thanks! Where are you applying these rules? uBlock Origin? or will this just work with any adblocker type thing?

It should work with pretty much all the ad blockers.

This completely worked for me (for now) with uBlock Origin in Firefox on Linux.

Thanks again! Much appreciated!

Thank you! you made my day!

So useful, thanks. I hate just random stuff popping up.

I quite like it, after having seen it in the, ahem, adult spaces. But seriously though, it's a good enough feature for just checking out whether a video is interesting enough to watch or whether the title and thumbnail are just clickbait, which they often are for making the creators money. It saves me a click or new tab which is even more annoying than hovering over a video.

> I quite like it, after having seen it in the, ahem, adult spaces.

Those of us old enough to have witnessed the early days of YouTube remember that their previous video-preview-on-hover feature was also lifted directly from those same adult spaces :)

Indeed, many such technologies have arisen from adult spaces: https://www.businessinsider.com/porn-behind-internet-technol...

I remember attempts were made to improve upon by actually following through video contents and adding it to watch history, which not many in that industry did, if any, and were soon reverted back to exact same style as used in the said industry. I thought YouTube one upped the game, but they didn't. That was interesting.

They're also experimenting with rolling out 'most watched' graphs on the timebar when you're seeking in a video so you can see which parts are the most popular.

Personally I'm all for it. It's kind of embarrassing for Youtube to be lacking good usability features that adult entertainment sites have.

Once again, following applies: Criminals and the porn industry are the two common early adopters.

It's not surprising that those industries are more than willing to pay a premium for innovation and execute. They can't survive on branding and marketing so must innovate to stay ten steps ahead of the competition just to stay afloat.

I like the previews. The annoying part is that Cmd+click opens it both in a new tab (expected) and in the same tab (unexpected). Someone’s being cheeky with JavaScript “links” and for all the shit that Google devrels give everyone else about accessibility … akhem

This is the worst! I'm using Linux and Windows so its Ctrl, but the same thing happens... Surely this is a bug they will fix.

I like the preview, but I don't like that youtube is basically playing the video (without audio) and if I watch 30 seconds, then click through, it starts me 30 seconds in.

For me the delay on the home screen is long enough that I don't do it accidentally. It happens when I search as well and it's really useful when seeing if it's what I am looking for. I appreciate that it's muted. I have gotten used to resting the mouse cursor outside the thumbnail. I guess I changed my behavior without realizing, I can't remember when that feature was enabled for me.

I personally find it useful as long as the video stays muted while autoplaying. I love the mobile search even more where the subtitles on videos work in preview mode, I wish that feature was brought to desktop.

There is a "Send feedback" option in the sidebar. I am unsure if you need to be logged in to see it, I don't think so because YouTube in incognito has the the option send it too. I recommend you send feedback.

The subtitles on desktop do work for me (and I agree that's a great function). I think you'll have to mess around your settings somehow. I got A/B tested to this hover feature months ago and the subtitles have been working all that time.

You can disable it with the "inline playback" toggle here: https://www.youtube.com/account_playback

If you don't happen to be in some or other test group, that is. No guarantees :)

Absolutely maddening that feature.

Perfect! Thank you.

I have to thank you too. I would've not known where to even look for that.

Any way to disable if I don't have an account? Asking for a friend

> Asking for a browser with Cookie Autodelete.

FTFY :)

Some custom stylesheets or javascript would make short work of it. Extensions like `tampermonkey` or `violentmonkey` could inject them.

Obvious but still: Only ever run code that you yourself have written, or scripts you have personally verified to be safe.

It seems to revert to on again if you clear cookies, same as autoplay. Hostile UX.

If I remember correctly, this has been there for a while. You can disable it at

[YourProfile] > Settings > Playback and performance > Turn OFF the "Inline Playback" Button.

The weird thing is, this settings do not seem to stick when logging off and then in again. I remember setting this off few times.

It’s pretty crazy how few options YouTube has for such a large website.

I don't seem to have that option? https://p.mort.coffee/fLT.png

I'm in Firefox, where the feature exists but looks a bit different. Maybe the setting only exists for Chrome.

Fuck Google and their consistent clearly intentional anti-Firefox behavior. Google's websites are in general the worst when it comes to cross-browser compatibility.

>Fuck Google and their consistent clearly intentional anti-Firefox behavior. Google's websites are in general the worst when it comes to cross-browser compatibility.

You'd think this might be grounds for some antitrust litigation, oh... wait a second.... I found a link: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_litigation

ps: I've never come across the coffeepaste before, but I love it. Especially love the man page at https://p.mort.coffee/ for example

Interesting how none of those lawsuits are antitrust related to their anti-competitive behavior in the browser or search engine markets, you 'd have thought that would be fertile ground for litigation.

Glad you like coffeepaste :) I made it a while ago since I had issues with all the other alternatives I found. Feel free to use my instance or set up your own if you want.

Really cool!

> The file will be deleted

> a while after the last read.

How long after?

It's configurable, but in my instance at p.mort.coffee, it's 30 days.

Google's fight against Firefox isn't so visible on YouTube. I'd say it's mobile, Google Drive and their video calls. Google does a lot of A/B testing and I'm surprised someone on HN wouldn't blame that first. I'm not ruling out that Google may have done that against Firefox though. It's worth noting that YouTube's Polymer site was always very slow on Chrome too and it was never just about shadow DOM v0.

Do they actually do any user testing before launching a feature? Or did someone important at YouTube think it was a cool idea and greenlighted it.

How about doing a poll before a video asking people if they like the feature? If they answer no then ask if they'd like it turned off? Beats moving on to the next new feature.

I know for a fact that they do a bunch of A/B testing at a time. The metrics they measure to decide if the change was effective isn't transparent. I wish there was a straightforward way but I imagine the "Send feedback" in the sidebar includes a way for them to see what experiments are active on your account.

Did they write the headings of the report backwards maybe?

They must be in discord of what they are measuring vs. what their vocal audience is. Their vocal audience is probably there to browse around and engage amongst themselves, while they are measuring retention and content engagement. Those user stories are not so subtly different.

Blame TikTok?

https://www.youtube.com/account_playback

> Inline Playback -> Off

What exactly is overstepping about it? Just turn it off lol

>Just turn it off lol

Not an option on my account.

Same. No such option.

Shows for me next to 'Browsing' (the last option/section).

Interestingly enough, I turned this off some time ago, and just yesterday, I noticed the hover behavior, and had to go back and turn it off again. I wonder if some / all of user prefs for this field got botched?

Thankfully, unlike sibling comments to mine, I still had the option and it worked no problem.

I don't have a YouTube account, so this is not an option it seems

Wow. Thank you.

Comments like this make me glad that I made the thread. HN can be pretty cool sometimes.

This reminds me of when they introduced the autoplay when scrolling on the mobile app. I'm fine with getting an audio-free preview, assuming I'm not on mobile data, but they originally started kicking the videos they'd preview into your history. I had a moderately well trained profile that kept my junk to a minimum but boy-oh-boy, all these "useless" (as in no value to me) YT shorts started invading my recommendations because of the feedback loop it gave itself.

I think I either finally found the option to not, or they reverted the change that put them into your history. Or maybe it's still happening. I've also noticed while scrolling on mobile (android) app, I found myself seeking the video preview, instead of scrolling up, because they enabled the ability to scrub these previews and my scrolling digit would often just land on the 5 pixel tall scrollbar element. Weird choices. Am a premium subscriber - I like to tailor my account to videos I want and take the time to deny suggestions and describe why in the hopes I get recommended less TikTok > YouTube repost junk.. did a pretty good job until they messed with it.

They definitely still show up in your watch history, at least on iOS.

What a dumpster fire of an app. I really don’t know how any of the people who work on it feel good.

I hate it. You can disable it (for now at least) via Settings -> Playback and Performance -> Inline playback.

I have switched to Piped as a frontend alternative to Youtube, and Libreddit for Reddit. I don't understand why are they so adamant on making the UI worse every passing day. I absolutely loathe the reddit redesign.

I use the old.reddit, don't find it terrible, but yes completely agree about the redesign.

old.reddit.com works fine on desktop but displays itself as a desktop site on mobile so becomes difficult to navigate on the tiny screen of my phone.

I tried using i.reddit.com on my phone, but the links constantly redirects itself to the new reddit redesign and prompts me repeatedly to login, does not show me half of the replies and no access to NSFW subs.

At this point I became so frustrated with the site I just stopped using reddit altogether but found out about libreddit and teddit soon after.

> the links constantly redirects itself to the new reddit redesign and prompts me repeatedly to login, does not show me half of the replies and no access to NSFW subs.

i think some javascript is broken on the i.reddit.com site - you have to have logged in for it to work. But it works good most of the time after logging in.

It is forever amazing how artificially heavy everything is.

Wow. That is poetic and true.

Alternative to YouTube (same content, better UX/UI/frontend):

https://invidious.io/

https://yewtu.be/

Thanks! I appreciate this!

Does it use the same recommendation algorithm? I don't have a YouTube account but (sadly) do still watch a lot of the recommended videos

No, I think there are fewer and different videos in the sidebar.

This is "growth inwards": when a business unit can't keep growing outwards, it turns to this pathological mode where it squeezes out all value from its users and reputation. In practice, the corporate peons must find new ways to extract this value, regardless of whether it hurts the org in the long run.

The bottom line must grow every quarter, or the shareholders will not be happy!

(edit: I hate it!)

Another long standing annoyance is those links to other videos that pop up before my current video has ended. It always interferes with the last portion, usually when something important and climactic is being shown. There used to be a way to block these “annotations” but they removed it.

Oh god, those are the worst. Often you will be trying to watch the end of the video and you can't because they obscure text or other crucial images. Seriously, who at Youtube decided this was a good idea?

So if creators start tacking 30 seconds of black on the end of their videos will that avoid this issue?

Quite likely.

I'm getting tired of the proliferation of "tooltip" style popups recently. It seems as if every other pixel triggers a popup and every time I want to read actual content, it becomes obscured because my mouse touched a hot zone or was parked on a trigger

For me, the autoplay was there and fine. The growing big is new, annoying and similar to Amazon/Netflix. There was no need to change it.

This has severely limited my usage of Netflix. I'm pretty close to cancelling it.

You can disable autoplay for Netflix, weirdly only in the account settings that you cannot reach from any app but only in a web browser.

If you could scrub through the video by hovering over the play progress bar it'd be useful. Like it is it's kind of pointless, since I usually don't care about the previewing the intro of a video.

This is a unique and interesting point that I haven't seen mentioned elsewhere in the thread.

I believe this is a feature on the mobile app.

Edit: Oh I completely misread it. Yes the autoplay on front-page was annoying as hell but it was only on for a few weeks and now it is off. They must be doing A/B testing.

I had not idea why I read it as thumbnails in player. I leave the original comments below in tact.

Interesting to see comments here so far.

I like it, a lot. I can now glance at the thumbnails and jump to section I am looking for. And the thumbnails are so fast it is near if not a native experience. ( I mean the thumbnails, not the actual playback experience which is far from native ) To be point I wonder how it is done. But I never had time to look it up.

Things I want would be Bitrate for Video and Audio in "Stats for nerds and better Skipping Video performance. Not sure why video experience in browser are always subpar. Especially considering most of my video are now consumed in browser.

I use the YouTube app more than any other app and there is so much I absolutely hate about it.

But the main thing that triggers me is that in the settings there is a place to suggest a feature or report a bug. And in that "form" it doesn't come up with a text box like the I am writing in now, it has choices for functionality that they are just choosing to not add in. "No way to select don't show this video" .. etc. I still can't believe that to refresh the videos on AppleTV my only options are to restart the app or login into guest and then back into my account real quick. Kicker here is with a custom remote on the AppleTV for whatever reason the YouTube menu side scroll breaks and won't let me select 1 spot over, it goes over two spots. So inevitably I have to have the Apple remote on hand too to get new videos.

But again, I use the app a lot. I fear updates to it like the plague. They have never ever added enjoyment to the app. Only taken away features and made things worse.

I like the autoplay feature(already existed before this recent change), but I'm not a fan of it making it bigger.

The biggest problem I have with it, seems to be a bug, middle/command clicking the video, will often(not always) open the video in both a new tab, and the existing tab, when what it should be doing is only opening it in the new tab.

I usually scroll through YouTube and add videos I want to watch to "watch later". Before this change I could just hover on the video and click the button to add it to WL playlist. Now I need to hover, wait and click this unnecessarily big and ugly "ADD TO WATCH LATER" button

Yes this is massively annoying. Especially since the "old" watch later button will appear for a flash moment where it used to be.

"Does anyone else find this annoying as hell?"

I find it annoying that an unpleasant user experience is generally viewed solely as a problem of the particular website and not a problem of the software available to access websites. For example, the user cannot simply switch to a browser that only supports a subset of the HTML protocol, e.g., one that does not support autoplay. Instead users must expend energy to try to modify the default behaviour of the browser or add functionality that does not exist. Here, the website operator is also a browser vendor. I find that troublesome. To avoid the repercussions, I do not use a browser to interact with YouTube. I do not use an app either.

> I do not use a browser to interact with YouTube.

… so you use command line?

that makes sense assuming they just YouTube-dl the videos they want to watch... Certainly not my preferred method but you do you.

Yes, I search from command line, get JSON returned. Extract info I need from JSON, titles, descriptions, URLs, etc., and then download videos from command line, using tiny shell scripts. (I do not use youtube-dl because I rarely ever need to download videos that use a dynamically-generated sig value.) Additionally, I have scripts to download lists of all videos from any given YouTube channel. No browser or Javascript needed.

I see you getting downvoted for this, but I don't see anything you said that is incorrect. Sure, the way that you use the platform may not be practical for 99.9% of people, but it doesn't make it any less valid.

I appreciate it, 37. Thank you.

It is annoying. It interferes with my browsing.

It's definitely a bit annoying. I use the "add to queue" button a lot, and now the time between when that button pops up after I hover on a video and when that button disappears as hovering over the video causes it to autoplay is pretty miniscule. It's also a little less pleasant to have to actually be careful about where you leave the mouse pointer as you navigate a search.

There's an option to disable it though, and you can always use something like ublock origin to just kill the offending elements.

Yes this is my problem too. It breaks my add to watch later workflow.

I didn't even notice it until now. I went to check after reading your post. For me it takes one or two seconds for autoplay to start. Now that I've seen it, I must say that I don't mind this feature. I think that it could be useful.

The reason why I like is the fact that thumbnail image is not necessarily the accurate representation of the video. Short clip should reveal much better what is the real content of the video.

I find it useful, ymmv. It's a better preview for me than the thumbnails they used to use, or the slideshow they were using before this change.

There's also a certain format on YT where a person says they are going to discuss X in the title, then wastes minutes belaboring on tangents and details before spending 5 seconds discussing X proper. This scrobbable preview helps me evaluate prior if their videos are worth watching.

I don't mind that it autoplays with captions, that's actually pretty useful. I can sometimes get the gist of a video and not need to watch it at all.

But it is annoying that videos I've hovered over show up as watched, since I definitely haven't watched it yet and I might end up skipping it later if I think I've watched it already.

There is a bit of delay before popping bigger. Didn't affect my youtube browsing so far.

I don't really mind it, but what I mind more is that autoplay no longer pauses if you've scrolled down into the comments. YouTube used to wait for you to scroll back up to the top of the fold before allowing autoplay to advance.

I don't like it at all

Love it

I already have the extension which changed the thumbnail back to a random point in the video

This lets me quickly skip around the middle of a video to see if it's something worthwhile or clickbait

Autoplay should be banned. Period. Also, hover menus should be strongly discouraged (they should really be banned as well but people must have the freedom to make mistakes).

Especially when they zoom/increase the size of the element.

I thought most designers learned back in the 2000s that you shouldn't make clickable elements increase in size on hover, for accessibility/usability reasons.

People do quite a bit of complaining about the YouTube main page but I can honestly say that I have never once intentionally used it. Why would people go there?

I used to live by the subscriptions page, but for some reason interesting channel recommendations have been sneaking onto the home page for me.

YouTube still doesn't quite understand that if I happen to watch one video about cats, or a fish tank, that that doesn't mean it should suddenly show me only videos about those. Or that there's a large subset of videos that I don't really need to see today, since I just watched them yesterday (already discussed in a HN thread last week, IIRC).

So given that, you may want to give it another chance. Definitely set your expectations low.

I don't have a Alphabet or Google or YouTube account, and I greatly dislike the company, but I will say that their recommendations are usually pretty good.

I like the preview with the caps, that’s nice. What does slightly annoy me is that the animation is a bit “wobbly” for lack of better terms.

I think the preview has been there for a little while. I like that feature.

The div zooming by 120% seems new, and I am not fond of it.

I like this new feature a lot actually. Helps me preview videos before clicking on them.

I think it's a pretty innocuous change and I'm not sure it's worth anybody's energy to complain.

Why is it bad that the videos now get slightly bigger when you over over them? The auto-play on hover is not new.

Shorts. How do we hide and disable all shorts

Annoying and I have a plugin to disable them.

i really like this feature and use it all the time.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com