Hacker News Reader

Comment by swinnipeg | Hacker News Reader

Many of these bikes are not a great compromise at all, they are just all together bad.

A "dual suspension bikes" for $200, will be both bad on a trail, and on a road. It will have terrible rims, terrible tires, terrible everything, and will be designed to break near-immediately. All sizzle, no steak.

Walmart could have a bike for the same price with simpler, less flashy features, that was better in everyway. Except it wouldn't pretend to be a capable full squish bike.

IF walmart was to put their heft behind a rock solid single speed it would be be an exceptional win for consumers.

View on HN

The thing is people are often not all that clued up on 'the tech jargon' and so would be unlikely to purchase a single speed, non-suspension plain jane bike when right next to it (for the same or similar price) is something that has (fake) suspension, shoddy gears etc but loudly proclaims 24 Speed, Comfort Suspension etc.

I mean caveat emptor but when manufacturers stoop to such deceptive practices as fake/non-functional suspension pieces then you can't always blame the purchaser*

(* not that you were btw - just a seperate train of thought).

I don't mean compromising between different use cases, I mean compromising on budget. Different people have different needs. Many people are okay with terrible rims, tires, etc, because they're not expecting to use the bike much. A bike that lasts 90 hours may sound like crap to you, but that's enough for a twenty minute round trip every weekday for a year, which for many people could be perfectly adequate.

The claim that something can be made higher quality for the same price seems highly dubious. Cheap bike makers are throwing on these flashy features instead of making something high quality because it is cheaper to do so. I'm sure walmart would love to sell a bike for the same price that more people wanted, or at least something people liked enough to repurchase. The fact is people looking for high quality bikes aren't looking at walmart, or at the very least would look at reviews prior to their purchase. Those who don't know what they are buying generally don't really care what they are buying - and there's nothing wrong with that.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com