The Dissolution of the Nutrition Science Initiative

Not long after, he says the problem with pathological science is they establish what they are seeing based on premature data, go public, and then dig in their heels at that point — he's saying it about an adversary but could easily be said about himself. Its like he's almost self aware, but he's so sure of his view that his framework for understanding bad science doesn't apply to him.

I think there's a bit of a motte and bailey that happens with Taubes proponency, where one can say there is this underappreciated role of insulin in obesity, vs the hard line he takes which is the standard energy balance model is "not even wrong", i.e., absolutely no role for a caloric surplus outside of his framework. So sure, demonstrating that a keto diet can be a game changer for a type 2 diabetic is great and Taubes has a hand bringing that to the mainstream. But that doesn't also affirm his hard, and hard to believe stance on the topic. I think what I mean is clear if you listen to the conversation about Doritos starting around 2:16, where Taubes suggests there is no hyperphasia without near-instant hormonal disregulation from adipose tissue in response to a dorito entering the mouth, and it has nothing to do with the team of food scientists that make sure they are additively delicious. Taubes could be 50-90% correct in his hypotheses, but he takes it beyond that point to the absurd and further that there is no reconciling his beliefs with competing hypotheses.

I hate to be the 'just listen to the 200 minute podcast' guy, but it really is fascinating in the juxtaposition I mentioned and I'd be keen to know how much you agree or think I am off base if you did give it a listen.

As for your Covid worries, isn't it already established that Omicron is more contagious but with much milder symptoms? Or is that still unconfirmed? Not trying to start a flame war here but it's fairly obvious at this point that barring imprisoning everyone in their homes, Covid contraction still happens quite a lot out there. We can't seem to stop it, only reduce the rate at which it happens.

My mother-in-law just died of cancer in October. Her heavy sugar habit must have contributed to how fast it spread. In the hospital, the meals they provided were all loaded with sugar and stripped of fiber and fat. So, it affects us all, xbecause the full industrial might of the modern world is turned to pushing sugar on the population.

That explains it.

From that article, it’s clear their funded study didn’t back up their priors and they ultimately cut funding and discredited the research.

From the link:

"If this was an animal study, they’d have thrown them out,” he says. “Euthanized them and started over.”