Hacker News Reader

Comment by kseistrup | Hacker News Reader

I find both Granny Smith, Jonagold, and Gala absolutely uninteresting, but I'm not very fond of apples…

The only apple I eat regularly is Nicoter (Kanzi's organic sibbling).

I've always found the popularity of Granny Smith in particular to be bizarre. They are really horrible apples, good only for cooking. Cox's Orange Pippin is superior in every way including a much more interesting and rounded flavour.

Actually, I do have a theory why it's so popular. It's because of the phrase "an apple a day keeps the doctor away". People regard them as medicine rather than a treat, so it makes sense for them to be disgusting.

Apple farmers I've worked for your me they reckon its market share is just about having something that contrasts with the other colours on the shelf in the supermarket.

Granny Smith is a baking apple. I don't know anyone who eats it raw. It's great for pies and crumbles and apple crisp.

Here in Denmark Granny Smith is pimped as a regular apple for eating raw. When you say it's a baking apple, it makes more sense that the taste is so unappetizing when eaten raw.

Edit: typo

Yeah, the balance of sweet and tart that you would expect from an eating apple is missing from Granny Smith, because that would be lost when you dump it in a pie crust with a cup of sugar. It also explains why the apple is so firm, because it's expected to soften when baked. You can eat it raw, I just don't know why you would.

No, the Granny Smith is an eating apple (for instance this BBC Good Food page -- https://www.bbcgoodfood.com/glossary/apple-glossary -- lists it in the eating apples, not in the cooking apple list with varieties like Bramley). It might not be to your taste, but some people like it. I have other varieties I prefer but I'll happily eat a Granny Smith if that's what's in the fruit bowl.

Edit: in fact, I just picked one out of the fruit bowl. Yes, it's not the sweetest apple in the world, but not everything has to be. And the crunch of biting into it is good.

It was my go to apple as a kid, but that was back in the day when the other options were red and yellow delicious.

Even with an abundance of options today, I still enjoy them on occasion.

To each their own ;-)

In the US it’s a mainstream eating apple. Which isn’t to say it’s great for eating, considering the ultimate mainstream eating apple is the awful Red Delicious. In for example a gas station, they will stock Red Delicious and Granny Smith so you have your choice of red or green apple. Granny Smith is a better apple than Red Delicious: it’s sweet and pleasantly tart. It’s got a weird texture though. And it’s too hard, as you point out in another comment.

Better second-tier mainstream apples here are Macintosh and Golden Delicious, before you start getting to the premium apples like Gala, Fuji, and the varieties people are loving on in this thread.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com