Ask HN: Why isn't there a simple, seemless Windows screen recording app? | Hacker News Reader

Ask HN: Why isn't there a simple, seemless Windows screen recording app?

8 pointsBraverHeart15 comments

Seriously, I looked everywhere and I couldn't find anything that does the following in a straight forward way and with minimalist UI:

- Shortcut to show region selection (Something like taking a screenshot in Windows (SHIFT+WIN+S)

- After region selection, start recording immediately

- Stop recording and save in a predefined location

Features:

- Configure in advance whether to save as MP3 or GIF

Every tool I tried is either too bloated or has some extra steps that ruins the fluidity of the UX.

The closest thing I found is LiceCap, but this tool is GIF exclusive and has extra UI steps.

For someone that takes screen recordings every day, any tool becomes too tedious.

I wish I could build it myself, but time constraints.

View on HN

ShareX can do this.

It lets you select a region + record with one hotkey, detects window borders and snap to those as regions, optionally converts between gif/mp4, and uploads to a variety of sites. Also handles screenshots with a quick built-in image editor, file uploads, and more. <10MB total size so fairly lightweight.

It's open source, too!

https://getsharex.com/

I use the built in screen recorder:

Window+Shift+S to take a screenshot

Window+G to bring up recording mode, then

Window+Alt+R to start recording

https://betanews.com/2015/07/19/windows-10-secret-screen-rec...

It may be more than you want by I swear by

https://www.techsmith.com/screen-capture.html

I use it for screenshots, demos, bug reports and other software dev tasks.

For other work I think the capture functionality is great but if I really need to edit video I will load it into Adobe Premier.

Thank you for the suggestion, but I would file this under too bloated for the job in terms of features and size. I mean LiceCap is less than 1MB in size and it does a third of what's needed, Snagit is a 300Mb+ download!

How does the bloat really affect you?

I don't have a rational answer for this, it just seems that such a simple task, would need a simple solution.

Just downloading and installing this took minutes and kind of stressed my computer and when I finally tried to launch it, it asked me to sign up before I can use it, so I abandoned and uninstalled it.

I can't recommend this to someone else, when it has such a barrier to entry.

I see it as a valuable tool I use for my work.

I paid for a license when I was self employed and my current employer has a procurement deal with TechSmith and bought me a license for my work laptop.

SnagIT is a great tool - I just found it myself this year.

Hands down recommend SnagIt. It works like a dream has integrated cloud storage options, so save on 1 machine and edit on all others instantly, plus with SnagItX all your file formats are editable across windows and mac. It's a no brainer.

https://www.techsmith.com/snagit-workplace-communication.htm...

Consider Captura: https://mathewsachin.github.io/Captura/ and if that doesn't work for you, you can always fork it.

Warning: there are a lot of Captura clones in the Microsoft store, download it only from Github.

Not bad! The closest solution to what I wanted, unfortunate that it's no longer maintained :-(, any idea what happened?

https://github.com/NickeManarin/ScreenToGif

ShareX fits the bill. Also a fantastic screenshot tool. And will auto upload to tons of different online services, your own services, or just store locally.

Thank you, this looks interesting, though it has a lot of other features.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com