Hacker News Reader

Comment by gregsadetsky | Hacker News Reader

Hey,

I tested it here a few times, logging in with a wrong password does not generate an email, while logging in with the correct password from a new IP does generate that "Someone just used your master password to try to log in to your account from a device or location we didn't recognize" email.

Could you try again logging in with a completely wrong password (to see if you get a email) and then logging in with the correct password from a new IP?

Also, you can verify that those kinds of events (wrong password and correct password from new IP) are logged in the LastPass Account History. Instructions to get the Account History are here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29708122

View on HN

Interesting. I tested twice before with the wrong password and vpn and it generated the email but was not able to get in. I assume it would still show in account history because that event is the login verification email event.

It isn’t sending that email for me at this point so maybe something has been corrected and LastPass will acknowledge something soon.

For me, the behavior is:

* Connecting from my own IP with wrong password: It tells me to "Check my master password and try again."

* Connecting from another IP with wrong password: It tells me to "Check your inbox for an email from LastPass: <myemail**@gmail.com>" and also to check my login info.

It's a bit odd that it tells me to check my email even though the master password I provided was incorrect.

Yeah, it's as if the error message (when using a wrong password on a new IP) was trying to not say that the password is wrong. It's just saying "check your email", just as if you had typed in the correct password (from a new IP).

But when you did attempt to login with a wrong password, you never received a "Someone just used your master password to try to log in to your account from a device or location we didn't recognize" email, correct?

Correct, at 10:20 eastern I did receive the verify device/location email using an invalid password but it is no longer sending the email.

That would truly be the best outcome possible -- that LastPass sent out "Someone just used your master password" emails incorrectly i.e. those were false positives.

They are saying it’s just a credential stuffing attack and being that my master passphrase is only used for LastPass I’m hoping that is all that is going on. Their statement does say “It’s important to note that, at this time, we do not have any indication that accounts were successfully accessed” but I would still like confirmation the emails were sent even on invalid attempts.

But if your master passphrase is only used for LastPass (as is exactly my case -- I've never used it elsewhere), how can it can be credential stuffing? Or was the password breached from LastPass itself in the past? That's possible, but then it doesn't jell with people having this same issue with accounts created in November 2021.

As far as I can tell, the "Someone just used your master password to try to log in to your account from a device or location we didn't recognize" email we all received was only sent when a correct password was used. Incorrect passwords did not trigger that email.

But yes, it would be great to learn that those emails were sent incorrectly i.e. it was a false positive (i.e. someone tried to login with a wrong password, but the email above was sent anyway). It's still not great that the wrong kind of email was sent, but that would be a low level bug.

I was just able to trigger the email again on a bad password. Going to figure out the exact 123’s and screen record.

I was never able to successfully trigger the false positive last night but I believe the most recent explanation from LastPass is in line with what I have been seeing. Intermittent false positive emails.

https://www.techradar.com/au/news/lastpass-accidentally-scar...

Yeah, just saw their new announcement (thanks for doing those tests yesterday by the way!)

I don't know how much to read into their use of "some" and "likely" i.e. "some of these security alerts, which were sent to a limited subset of LastPass users, were likely triggered in error"

I would want to know whether they can demonstrate that wrong passwords were used in this attack. And have an explanation for those users who received the email a 2nd time after changing their passwords.

Just making sure, when you say wrong password, was the password completely wrong, or you changed the lower/upper case? There's a separate conversation on this topic here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29708869

And again, to confirm, you used the wrong password and received an email saying "Someone just used your master password to try to log in to your account from a device or location we didn't recognize" ?

Thanks!

Reply on news.ycombinator.com