By this logic we should surrender our arms and legs as well, and really just die.
That doesn't follow at all "by this logic".
It does if you subscribe to slippery slope fallacies
It does. GP's entire argument is that power that can be abused should not exist.
I’m saying this specific power, you’re extrapolating that to mean I think this means all power instead of starting the discussion about what makes this power different that it deserves different treatment. Taking someone’s opinion and arguing against an extreme extrapolation of it doesn’t leave much room for discussion.