Hacker News Reader

Comment by ziml77 | Hacker News Reader

As someone who uses Everything many times per day, I can say that there is a significant amount of benefit. I don't think I'd be able to function at work without being able to instantly search all my files. The lack of a similar solution on Linux is one of the big barriers to me using it. The best options I've seen there all refresh the index on a schedule.

View on HN

As always, it depends. Doing a hefty build can make half a million files on my machine - even minor additional file-creation latency can add up VERY quickly in that scenario. And frankly I do far more builds per day than I do `find`, though the build system likely does a fair number of shallow ones.

In user-visible-oriented folders though, oh heck yes it should all be indexed.

I have to use Windows for work and I never see Everything take any CPU ever, even when I have to compile (maybe not a million files though). It's all asynchronous so builds aren't slowed down, indexing happens in the background but never takes long and when you need it it's all there because as you said you don't need to search for files every second.

So, in practice, it works.

I suppose eBPF could be used to implement real-time index updates, which could be neat. Maybe I'll investigate doing that as a little side project. Though from a quick look, doing it efficiently may require some modification to mlocate's updatedb program (depending on how -U works exactly...).

Reply on news.ycombinator.com