Hacker News Reader

Comment by tconfrey | Hacker News Reader

I'd almost swap to an iPhone for access to this app!

Org is amazingly powerful but as someone here commented recently, the learning curve is a brick wall! I was an emacs user for decades before getting up enough momentum to tackle org and make it useful for me.

That said, I think org mode text is a much better basis for PKM and Productivity tools than the proprietary or markdown based tools that seem to be gaining in popularity. Its great to see tools like this one, plus Flat Habits[1] and LogSeq[2] join BrainTool (mine)[3] as part of an org-based ecosystem.

[1] https://flathabits.com/ [2] https://logseq.com/ [3] https://braintool.org

View on HN

Seems that org-mode is powerful enough to not only convert vim->Emacs, but also Android->iOS

VIM user here. Yes, after over two decades of VIM I've almost completely converted over to SpaceMacs thanks to org-mode. It is that good.

As a Vim user, orgmode has always been very tempting. I’m watching this new Neovim plugin now: https://github.com/kristijanhusak/orgmode.nvim/tree/0.1

BrainTool looks incredible. I'm on Firefox, so can't use it yet, but this is the _exact_ tool I wish was integrated into my browser.

My workflow is almost always:

1. need to solve $problem 2. do a big Google, collating some mental state along the way 3. end up with a rudimentary understanding of $problem, with some books to grab, tools to consider, next steps to take 4. resolve $problem sufficiently _for now_ 5. leave those tabs to exist forever, repeat entire process in 6 months time when $problem comes up again

BrainTool looks like the shortcircuit I need.

It's a bit jankier, and I suppose updates don't work (delete & recreate would do it) but it's almost built in to FF: save all tabs to folder; open all from folder.

Yeah, that's close, but it's not _quite_ far enough (thanks for the suggestion though :)). I've tried that in the past, but (like I said in the sibling comment), what I really want is "bookmark _with notes_". Sibling comment suggested that TST has a feature for that now, which looks really useful too.

Not exactly the same but as a fellow Firefox user here is one of my workflows (some practical stuff at the end):

- research one topic, using a Firefox instance with Tree Style Tabs, ctrl clicking each link I follow thereby opening it in a new leaf-branch, producing a tree of tabs documenting where I have been.

- research another topic... and another and then a few more.

- realizing after a few days I have more than 600 tabs open just in my research browser (I have one reserved for customer systems and mail, and on that I use mostly only Bitwarden, uBlock Origin and container tabs).

- I select one or more trees from my research browser, export them to markdown and get a nice indented markdown list of everything, copy those into Joplin, go back to Firefox and right click to close all selected tabs.

- that's it.

Hints: For this to work you need Firefox, the Tree Style Tabs (TST) Firefox extension as well as one or two TST extensions. Yes, on Firefox extensions can have extensions, and no, it doesn't bog down my browsers to any significant degree. The relevant TST extensions can be found linked from the TST addon page, yes they are also Firefox extensions but they won't help much without TST I think.

Yeah, I used to use TST (well, Sidebery) but have recently switched it off in an effort to curb my tabs (along with session restoration; now, it's a fresh browser every time, so I actually make the effort to archive something rather than leave it to linger forever).

I was unaware TST had an archive to Markdown feature though (just found the ticket in https://github.com/piroor/treestyletab/issues/1274) -- that's really really cool, and is something I'll try out! I think what I really want is "bookmark _with notes_", and that'd give me that, much like BrainTool would.

Wow, you seem to have read my mind! I’ve just recently gotten sick of dealing with the data portability nightmare that most apps have and am in the process of moving everything over to plaintext.

Logseq is exactly the notes app replacement I was looking for (as soon as it comes over to iOS).

Also, are you planning on porting BrainTool over to Firefox or safari?

I've had a lot of requests for Firefox. It will definitely get there in the reasonably near future. It currently runs on any Chromium-based browser, so Edge, Brave etc as well as Chrome. The FF api is just different enough (no support for tab groups) that the port is real work. This is the first request I've had for Safari tho, so its not on my list yet.

Plain text all the way!

Note that Logseq is made by the same team who wrote Obsidian, and Obsidian has iPhone and iPad apps already.

No they are not

Huh, I’d heard that several times, and that they’d moved to working on Obsidian like a sequel to Logseq. I can’t find anything showing that it’s the same team, though, so I guess you’re right until I see otherwise.

I think you're thinking of Dynalist.

OMG, you’re completely right. Yep, that’s exactly what I was thinking of. Thanks for the correction!

http://www.orgzly.com/ is a FOSS alternative for Android.

There's also Orgro[0].

[0]: https://f-droid.org/en/packages/com.madlonkay.orgro/

> [3] https://braintool.org

It looks really interesting. However, it asks for access to your browsing history, Google Drive, including all personal information associated with your Google account, which I think is a bit much given that I couldn't find any information about the author or source code.

BrainTool creator here. BT is very much a private and local first application, see the philosophy statement[1].

I use the absolute minimal permissions required to do the job. 'Browsing history' means I get access to the urls that tabs have open, there's no way to help you categorize them without that! Google Drive access is optional and only needed if you want to sync your data to a text file on your GDrive. BrainTool passes you to Google Auth and asks for permission to read and write the file on your behalf. It does not have access to any other information from your Google account.

The code is open sourced on my github[2]. Not sure what else you want to know about me, maybe my LinkedIn[3]?

I'm very much soliciting input from all sources RN, so if it looks interesting do give it a try and LMK what you think.

[1] https://braintool.org/overview.html [2] https://github.com/tconfrey?tab=repositories [3] https://www.linkedin.com/in/tconfrey/

Hi!

Thanks for the reply! I think adding GitHub and maybe LinkedIn links to your website would help establish a greater degree of trust. And please don't take it personally. It is just that given the high number of extensions stealing your data, I default to not trusting them.

Regarding Google Drive, the Google pop-up says:

"Select what BrainTool can access

- Associate you with your personal info on Google

- See your personal info, including any personal info you've made publicly available

- See your primary Google Account email address

- See, edit, create, and delete only the specific Google Drive files you use with this app."

The first three options cannot be unchecked and the last option needs to be selected for the integration to work. I don't know if it would be possible to require only the last option, but it would certainly make me more comfortable using BrainTool.

Otherwise, BrainTool looks great!

No offense taken, I completely understand and this is the kind of feedback I'm looking for!

The first version of BrainTool required the Google Drive integration to work and I quickly found that it was a barrier to adoption for some people and so made it optional. Unfortunately the first 3 popup items are not controllable by me. I am planning to add a local file integration option to avoid this altogether.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com