Hacker News Reader

Comment by d3nj4l | Hacker News Reader

Sure, you can keep things common with one codebase, but why does that codebase have to be flutter? IMO dart is a pretty meh language, and as others have pointed out flutter doesn't even use native controls. There's tons of options for common logic in native apps these days that don't mandate a choice of view layer.

View on HN

And IMO if you’re going to pick on Flutter, it’s surprising to me that you’d start with Dart. :)

I know JS is a lot better than it was 20 years ago and even half a dozen years ago, but it gave me enough PTSD over the years that compared to using JS for hybrid apps, Dart was such a breath of fresh air when I built my first Flutter app! I felt it made sense and just got out of the way so I could focus on what I wanted my app to do, and I didn’t even have to read any docs to start using it in Android Studio. And this is coming from having a lot of experience with compiled languages and a lot of Ruby in addition to JS.

Oh sure, I wanted to talk more about the "one codebase" idea - and with the state of FFI being what it is today, if you can pick anything, why pick Dart? is my thinking.

And I don't particularly hate Dart. It's fine. I've written a lot of Java so it's not much worse. But if I had free reign to choose, I'd much rather take Rust.

But for most users, do you really think they want to deal with manual memory management like with Rust? It's a UI framework not a backend performance critical one, I don't think Rust would make much sense. Dart is also compiled and gets good enough performance, at least way better than JS which is JIT not compiled to machine code.

Stateful hot reload is pretty awesome when doing UI work. On desktop that is pretty hard to find.

Also, as a TypeScript/Swift/Kotlin person, Dart is fine; sure I’d like algebraic data types but overall it is good. The tooling (auto completion etc) is great. And it has a few cool unique(ish?) features like cascade and every class is an ‘interface’.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com