- categorization and search;
- voting for every entry;
- maybe reputation system. Where peers regularly publishing good, high quality content get their 'karma'[1] upvoted. So when downloading you can choose people with higher reputation. Or when building catalog of materials in certain area of interest, you can filter only peers with certain threshold karma.
- incentive for peers to keep seeding whatever they downloaded at least until achieving certain ratio (say, 2:1). Maybe by rewarding with 'torrent tokens' that you can spend on downloading, commenting etc.[2]
- comments to every entry (published torrent). With means to combat spam, insults, irrelevant stuff etc. E.g. with voting system, where comments with, say, -3[3] votes become collapsed. Or/and with aforementioned 'tokens' that you spend when comment.
- personal blacklists to block people whose torrents/comments you don't want to see.
Maybe I'm reinventing the wheel here and something similar already exists, but for some reason not popular (since I never heard of it)? In that case we need to figure out why it didn't shoot and fix it to make it work.
[1] Your ID will be a cryptographic key a la cryptocurrency wallet.
[2] With rare but sought after torrents rewarding you with more tokens.
[3] Personally adjustable.